![]() |
![]() |
||
|
During my first few years of reviewing, my dirty little secret was that I wasn't overly fond of foreign film. Perhaps it was the trauma I experienced in high school, on a field trip to see The Sorrow and the Pity. Or perhaps it stemmed from the excruciating experience of having to sit through Scenes from a Marriage for a psychology class. In recent years, as I've attended more film festivals and as Hollywood has churned out an increasing amount of crap every year, I've developed a increasing appreciation for the work of directors whose work doesn't come out of pitch meetings. This trend has reached its apex in 2004, in which a foreign language film is my #1 of the year. As with most years, 2004 did not have an auspicious beginning, and without an installment of The Lord of the Rings to anticipate, and the Big Expensive Historical Heroic Epics, from Troy to King Arthur to Alexander (which I didn't even bother to see) each landing with a louder =thud= than the one before, one could have wondered where the quality films of 2004 were going to come from. But at the end of the day, there they were -- sprung from real life as documentaries continued to attain mainstream success, sprung from Europe and Asia, and sprung from the minds of young and talented filmmakers on a budget. Of course, given the glut of December releases and a particularly nasty upper respiratory infection that plagued me for the entire month, there are some I missed. Million Dollar Baby, which seems to be everybody's baby, opened the last week in December, and only in New York. The last screening of Vera Drake in my area was cancelled because the projector broke. I blinked, and so missed Enduring Love and P.S. And there are others. How wonderful would it be if studios would release these films over the course of the year, and then re-release those they're pushing for awards consideration, so that more of us could see them. But here they are, my favorites among my favorite films of 2004. All 15 of them. |
|||
![]() |
15. A HOME AT THE END OF THE WORLD (Dir: Michael Mayer) As religious lunatics in America continue to cram their own rigid ideas of what constitutes a family down everyone's throats, the more I find myself gravitating towards films like this one. Michael Mayer's treatment of Michael Cunningham's novel about a trio of friends who form a family as close -- and as dysfunctional -- as any, is so heartfelt and so real that you leave them only reluctantly at the end of it. Stage veteran Dallas Roberts is nothing short of sensational, and Colin Farrell, once you get past his awful hairstyles, shows a human side as the needy and confused Bobby. If you missed this one in theatres, don't miss it now on DVD. |
||
![]() |
14. ETERNAL
SUNSHINE OF THE SPOTLESS MIND While I didn't love Michel
Gondry's creation of Charlie Kaufman's meditation
(if anything coming out of Charlie Kaufman's mind
can be called meditative) on love as much as some
of my compatriots, there's no denying that this was
the most imaginative, while at the same time plaintive,
American movie of the year. Perhaps the biggest surprise
is their ability to turn Jim Carrey (in his most disciplined
performance yet) and Kate Winslet (in her most freewheeling
since Heavenly Creatures) into the kind of
screen couple you want to revisit in ten years. |
||
![]() |
13. KILL BILL, VOL. II The wildest ride on cinema
this year. If Quentin Tarantino seems at times like
a little kid seeking attention for "Look what
I did now!", there's no denying that he's a brilliant
stylist. Less bloody than the first film, less chopsocky
and more like a Sergio Leone spaghetti western than
a wuxia film, it's suspenseful, stylish, sometimes
outrageously funny (emphasis on outrageous), and a
quirky showcase for its offbeat cast. |
||
![]() |
12. FAHRENHEIT 9/11 (Dir: Michael Moore) Does any more ink need to be spilled about this film? Angry, important, and alas, just sloppy enough to provide the Republicans with fodder for their bile. |
||
![]() |
11. BROTHER TO BROTHER (Dir: Rodney Evans) This beautifully constructed film, in which the personal and cultural struggles of a young black gay artist are juxtaposed against a somewhat fictionalized version of the Harlem Renaissance, is a terrific debut by director Rodney Evans. The stylish flashbacks and use of vintage music give the film a larger-budget feel, while wonderful performances by Anthony Mackie and Roger Robinson as two generations of men dealing with the same struggle anchor the film. The protagonists of this film may be gay, but its themes transcend gender, sexual orientation and race. |
||
![]() |
10.
WILBUR
WANTS TO KILL HIMSELF (Dir:
Lone Scherfig)
The best seen-by-no-one film of the year. The idea of a dark romantic comedy about a suicidal man, directed by a Danish Dogme 95 disciple with an all-Scottish cast doesn't sound promising, but this one is so charming, so well-written, and so beautifully acted, particularly by newcomer and Hank Azaria lookalike Jamie Sives as the eponymous Wilbur, I defy anyone not to be won over. It's a Harold and Maude for the millennium, and an absolute winner. |
||
![]() |
9.
THE INCREDIBLES (Dir:
Brad Bird)
Because cultural critics never
seem able to let a cartoon be just a cartoon, this
wildly successful Pixar entry about a family of superheroes
forced to live in a kind of witness protection program
after the costs of litigating the aftermath of their
exploits become more than the government can withstand
has been derided as a Randian objectivist fantasy.
Churls. It's an absurd leap from Craig T. Nelson's
harried superhero dad and Holly Hunter's pluckily
flexible mom to John Galt and Dagny Taggart. This
is just a wildly inventive retro fantasy that pokes
good-natured fun at most of American culture without
ever being outright topical. Stealing the show is
director Brad Bird himself in the role of Anna Wintour's
mini-me. |
||
![]() |
8.
OUTFOXED: Rupert Murdoch's War on Journalism (Dir:
Robert Greenwald)
Another of Robert Greenwald's
quickie documentaries, Outfoxed reveals, as
if that were necessary, the role of Fox News as the
nearly official propaganda arm of the Bush Administration.
Aware of the magnitude of the target he's going after,
Greenwald does his homework, recording weeks upon
weeks of Fox News footage to make his points. With
on-camera analysis by many of the usual suspects,
including the ever-repentant David Brock, the film
also offers some inside insights by a former Fox news
personality whose voice is just barely disguised,
but is easily recognizable as that former ESPN guy
who also happens to be the only journalist in America
actually exploring the voting irregularities that
took place on November 2nd. |
||
![]() |
7.
THE STORY OF THE WEEPING CAMEL (Dir: Byambasuren Davaa, Luigi Falorni) Simply astonishing. A hybrid documentary in the style of Robert Flaherty, the film portrays a family of nomadic shepherds in Mongolia as they try to reconcile a newborn camel with the mother who has rejected it. Not only are filmmakers Byambasuren Davaa and Luigi Falorni providing a look into a culture most of us never see, but the film is also loaded to the gills with "cute factor", in the form not just of the newborn camel, who is a natural screen hog, but of young Uuganbaatar Ikhbayar, who plays the younger of two brothers. This is a heartwarming family film in the very best sense. |
||
![]() |
6.
CONTROL ROOM (Director:
Jehane Noujaim)
Fahrenheit 9/11 may have gotten all the press, but in order to understand how the Iraq war looks through the eyes of the people in the region, and arguably through the eyes of the reality-based community, Jehane Noujaim's look inside the Arab broadcaster Al-Jazeera is an eye-opener. In comparing the way U.S. broadcasters handled the early days of the war to that of Al-Jazeera, one would think they were covering two different wars. Widely derided as Islamic propaganda, the film is surprisingly sympathetic to those caught in the middle, such as U.S. Marine press spokesman Lt. Josh Rushing, who, unlike the Pentagon civilians he reported to, at least tried to understand the people and culture he was dealing with. |
||
![]() |
5.
MARIA FULL OF GRACE (Dir:
Joshua Marston)
Joshua Marston's astounding debut
as a director and author gave us a window into the
world of the drug mule that most of us had never considered.
This well-paced, thoughtful film contained some powerful,
if controversial imagery, such as the obvious parallel
between the Roman Catholic mass practiced in Latin
American countries, and the ritual swallowing of capsules
filled with heroin. Featuring a focused and determined
performance by impressive newcomer Catalina Sandino
Moreno, the film contains one of the most suspenseful
airplane flights you'll ever see. What would make
a young woman do something like this? The answer is
surprisingly simple. |
||
![]() |
4.
HERO (Dir: Zhang
Yimou)
2004 was undoubtedly the Year
of Flying Zhang Yimou, and while the director's late-year
entry House of Flying Daggers overshadowed
its only slightly less spectacular and far less preposterous
older brother, for my money, this color-themed variations
on an assassin's tale made for a more compelling film.
Maggie Cheung and Tony Leung as assassin/lovers burn
up the screen with a greater intensity than their
younger counterparts in Flying Daggers, for
all that theirs is not the film's driving story. |
||
![]() |
3.
SPRING SUMMER FALL WINTER...AND SPRING (Director: Kim Ki-Duk) Mel Gibson's spatter-porn epic
The Passion of the Christ may have generated
all the ink, but it was South Korean writer/director
Kim Ki-duk who delivered the most spiritually enlightening
film of the year. Tracing the life of a young Buddhist
monk through the seasons of his life, Spring Summer
plays out like a quiet meditation on life itself.
Gorgeously photographed, spare of dialogue yet fraught
with meaning, this film brings its Buddhist precepts
to a mass audience in a way no one could have imagined.
Compared with this film's quiet wisdom on man, nature,
and the cycle of life, Gibson's tub-thumping brand
Christianity seems something invented by barbarians. |
||
![]() |
2.
HOTEL RWANDA (Dir:
Terry George)
Far more than "the black
Schindler's List", Terry George's impeccable
profile of Paul Rusesabagina, who gave safe harbor
to over 1200 Hutu and Tutsi moderates during the Rwandan
genocide of 1994 brings both a country and an extraordinary
individual to life. Don Cheadle inhabits his character
without ever once going over the top. The genocide
is effectively handled without once resorting to the
kind of sledgehammer tactics that marred Spielberg's
so-called masterpiece. Impeccably paced, beautifully
constructed, well-cast, emotionally shattering, the
film zeroes in on individuals to tell the story of
the people of Rwanda and what they endured that terrible
year. This may be the most important film of the year. |
||
|
1. BAD EDUCATION (Dir: Pedro Almodovar) The most complete, "put-together" film of the year. A reverent homage to film noir leavened with some of Almodovar's trademark humor, this film boasts a near-perfect combination of an intricately crafted script, gorgeous cinematography, great direction, a terrific Bernard Herrmann-influenced score, and if you didn't think he'd already given one in Y Tu Mama Tambien or The Motorcycle Diaries, a career-making performance by Gael Garcia Bernal in three roles. This may be the gayest mainstream film of the year, but Almodovar handles the gay themes as being merely part of the plot just as sexuality would be in a film with straight characters, making this film an important milestone in bridging the divide between gay and straight cinema. |
||
|
THE BEST OF THE REST: The
Mother, Touching
the Void, Super
Size Me, Ray,
Undertow, Closer,
Collateral, Finding
Neverland
|
|||
| Review text copyright © 2004 Jill Cozzi and Mixed Reviews. All rights reserved. Reproduction of text in whole or in part in any form or in any medium without express written permission of Mixed Reviews or the author is prohibited. | |||
|
Back To Top | Home | Archive | E-Mail Harvest |
|||